CinePixo
ReviewsOff CameraMoviesPeopleTopicsCriticsStats
Sign inJoin
ReviewsOff CameraMoviesPeopleTopicsCriticsStats
CinePixo
ReviewsOff CameraMoviesWatchCriticsWritersStatsAboutEditorial StandardsContactPrivacyTermsRSS

CinePixo — a home for film-critic fandom.Built, filled and argued over by this community — the library, the artwork we license and host, the taxonomy and every signed review grow here, together.

  1. Home
  2. /Off Camera
  3. /Away From Set
  4. /Rohit Roy Calls TV a “Dustbin Medium” and Praises Film-Star Style
Away From SetEditorial feature

Rohit Roy Calls TV a “Dustbin Medium” and Praises Film-Star Style

The actor’s blunt split between television and cinema has reopened an old hierarchy in Indian entertainment—then put his own television career right in the blast zone. His comments came during a Kindle Cast YouTube conversation reported on September 12, 2026.

by Dorothy KwanSeptember 14, 20264 min read35 views
Rohit Roy
Rohit Roy · Ministry of Information and Broadcasting (GODL-India)

In this piece

  1. 01Rohit Roy draws the line between cinema and television
  2. 02His argument is about behavior before it is about scripts
  3. 03The clothes example turns the hierarchy personal
  4. 04A television veteran attacks the medium that built him

Rohit Roy has called television a “dustbin medium” and said film actors carry more “style” and “class” in public. He made the remarks during a conversation on the Kindle Cast YouTube channel, reported by Bollywood Hungama and IWMbuzz on September 12, 2026. For film readers, the point is not that an actor has discovered television’s expiry date. It is that Roy, who became known through the 1990s Doordarshan series Swabhimaan, has described the film industry’s class divide in terms of posture, clothes and paparazzi manners—and then dismissed the medium that made him famous.

Rohit Roy draws the line between cinema and television

Roy was asked about the “caste system” in entertainment, where television actors can be treated as inferior to film actors. His answer focused on public appearances. Film stars, he said, arrive with a “graceful, dignified, stylish, cool” front. Television actors, he argued, do not show the same “carriage.”

Then came the cleanest insult: “Cinema is cinema. It is for posterity. Television is a dustbin medium.”

In a separate account, IWMbuzz reported that Roy described television as something viewers consume today and forget tomorrow, like yesterday’s newspaper. He also complained about the volume of Indian television content and the repetition of similar material, saying there is “hardly any creativity.” The reporting does not establish whether he was talking about every television production or the dominant commercial format. Roy did not draw that line.

That missing line matters. “Television” can mean a daily soap, a limited series, a news broadcast or a prestige drama. Roy’s statement sweeps them into one bin, which gives it punch and takes away its precision.

His argument is about behavior before it is about scripts

Roy returned to conduct several times. He said actors must maintain grace and dignity in front of paparazzi, and should not make “stupid comments” or create “hoo-haa” because cameras are present. He contrasted that with gatherings of television actors, telling viewers to look at how they behave and decide for themselves.

This is a strange standard for an argument about artistic value. Roy began with television’s content and longevity, then shifted to manners at a public appearance. A film actor’s “front,” he acknowledged, is still a front. The difference, in his telling, is that the performance looks polished.

That is less a theory of cinema than a dress code with a box-office vocabulary. The film actor gets “carriage.” The television actor gets a warning about volume control.

The clothes example turns the hierarchy personal

Roy also discussed clothing. He acknowledged that film stars wear revealing outfits, but said there is a particular style in how those clothes are presented. He mentioned an unnamed woman who, in his words, “hardly wears anything,” and questioned why people would treat her badly.

How this piece was made

Editorial standards →

Editorial feature

A CinePixo feature whose more specific reporting or utility method has not been claimed.

In this piece

  • MC
    Mukesh Chhabrafilm director
  • Rohit Roy
    Rohit Roytelevision actor

Sources

  1. 01msn.com

In this piece

  1. 01Rohit Roy draws the line between cinema and television
  2. 02His argument is about behavior before it is about scripts
  3. 03The clothes example turns the hierarchy personal
  4. 04A television veteran attacks the medium that built him

The reports do not identify the woman. They also do not provide more detail about the incident Roy had in mind. That is where the comment stops being a general comparison and becomes a vague public example aimed at someone the audience is expected to recognize.

Roy’s larger claim remains clear: film actors know how to package provocation, while television actors can appear careless or undisciplined. It is a sharp distinction, but it depends on a highly selective view of what counts as professionalism. Clothes become evidence. A red-carpet entrance becomes a résumé.

A television veteran attacks the medium that built him

The contradiction is sitting in Roy’s own biography. Bollywood Hungama noted that he rose to prominence with Swabhimaan, while IWMbuzz listed later television successes including Des Mein Niklla Hoga Chand and Sanjivani. He has also appeared in films such as Fashion and Lokhandwala.

So this is not an outsider sneering at television from a film-only career. Roy worked in both industries and used that experience to rank them. That gives his comments a sharper edge, but it does not make them neutral. He is speaking from inside the hierarchy he describes.

The question about television’s status also produced a response from elsewhere. MSN reported that actor Mukesh Chhabra supported television actors after Roy’s “dustbin medium” remark, calling them “extremely professional.” The available reporting does not include a longer exchange between the two men, so there is no basis to call this a feud. It is a disagreement over what professionalism looks like—and who gets credit for it.

Roy has offered film readers a blunt little hierarchy: cinema lasts, television disappears; film stars know how to enter a room, television actors do not. The first claim is sweeping. The second is a judgment about performance off camera. Together they reveal what he thinks the film industry is selling when it sells “class”: not silence, not restraint, but a better-managed public pose.

· https://www.msn.com/en-in/news/other/mukesh-chhabra-supports-tv-actors-after-rohit-roys-dustbin-medium-remark-calls-them-extremely-professional/ar-AA2c7Ljp
  • 02bollywoodhungama.com · https://www.bollywoodhungama.com/news/features/rohit-roy-calls-television-dustbin-medium-also-says-there-is-a-certain-amount-of-style-class-in-film-actors/
  • 03iwmbuzz.com · https://www.iwmbuzz.com/television/news/rohit-roy-calls-television-a-dustbin-medium-says-tv-actors-lack-grace-and-dignity/2026/09/12
  • 04indianexpress.com · https://indianexpress.com/article/entertainment/bollywood/rohit-roy-calls-television-dustbin-medium-film-tv-actor-class-divide-10873655/
  • Every factual claim above is drawn from these. The reading of them is ours.

    Rohit Roy television dustbin medium commentsRohit Roy film actors style and classKindle Cast Rohit Roy interview September 2026television versus Bollywood actor hierarchyMukesh Chhabra supports TV actors Rohit Roy

    4 min read

    ShareXFacebookThreads
    Dorothy Kwan

    House critic, writing in the Kael tradition: criticism is first-person and physiological — what the film did to you in the dark. Distrusts respectability, prizes vitality over polish, and re-milks sacred cows on sight.

    Full profile and all work →

    More Away From Set

    All of it →
    Away From Set

    ‘Young Guns’ Cast Reunites as Third Film Waits in the Wings

    Emilio Estevez, Kiefer Sutherland, Charlie Sheen and three fellow Regulators gathered at FAN EXPO Dallas nearly four decades after the 1988 Western. The rare reunion also put fresh attention on the quietly pending ‘Young Guns 3.’

    Marcus Reid·Sep 14, 2026

    Away From Set

    Abhishek Pathak Says Drishyam: The Conclusion Turns Vijay Darker

    The director says Ajay Devgn’s final Drishyam film follows an original Hindi story, with Jaideep Ahlawat’s new cop pushing Vijay Salgaonkar into his most morally shadowed chapter. The film opens October 2, while Panorama Studios builds Korean, Spanish and English versions abroad.

    Dorothy Kwan·Sep 14, 2026

    Away From Set

    Sharon Ooja Says Bipolar Role Was Her Toughest Test Yet

    The Nollywood actor describes the mental strain of switching between tears, anger and laughter while playing a character with bipolar disorder. Her account offers a rare look at the work—and the cost—behind a demanding performance.

    Marcus Reid·Sep 14, 2026

    Away From Set

    Liam Neeson and Stella Stocker’s TIFF Hand-Hold Raises New Romance Questions

    At the Toronto International Film Festival on Sept. 12, Liam Neeson and Stella Stocker arrived together to promote Evil Genius and were photographed holding hands. Neither actor has confirmed a relationship, but the moment lands differently after Neeson said in 2024 that he was finished with dating.

    Marcus Reid·Sep 14, 2026